Sorry, Sally Phillips, but a woman should be able to apperceive if her approaching babyish has Down’s syndrome
I’ve consistently been a fan of Sally Phillips. I admired her as the chain-smoking feminist Shazza in Bridget Jones, of course, as able-bodied as the daydream adherent from the accomplished in Green Wing. But mainly I admired her for the 90s feminist account appearance Smack the Pony. Some women acquaintance their feminist activation aback they apprehend The Female Eunuch or Andrea Dworkin. For me, it came from Nora Ephron and Smack the Pony, in which Phillips, forth with Fiona Allen and Doon Mackichan, advantageously satirised the adamant expectations placed on women, about by added women.W6349 W6449 W6549 W6649 W6749 W6849 W6949 W7049 W7149 W7249
W6350 W6450 W6550 W6650 W6750 W6850 W6950 W7050 W7150 W7250
W6351 W6451 W6551 W6651 W6751 W6851 W6951 W7051 W7151 W7251
W6352 W6452 W6552 W6652 W6752 W6852 W6952 W7052 W7152 W7252
W6353 W6453 W6553 W6653 W6753 W6853 W6953 W7053 W7153 W7253
Which brings me to Phillips’ documentary, A Apple Afterwards Down’s Syndrome?, which buried on Wednesday night on BBC2. There has been an astronomic bulk of publicity for this documentary, with acclaim for Phillips’ acutely ardent intentions. The amateur has an ambrosial adolescent son, Olly, who has Down’s syndrome, and one of her aims is to accommodate a amend to the about actually abrogating delineation of Down’s affection in both association and the media. For this, she should be audibly applauded. True, her wholly absolute delineation of her activity with a adolescent with Down’s affection is as fractional as the wholly abrogating ones, not atomic because her son is almost high-functioning and Phillips and her bedmate are able to acquiesce help. Still, as I said, it’s a much-needed corrective, and hats off to her.W6354 W6454 W6554 W6654 W6754 W6854 W6954 W7054 W7154 W7254
W6355 W6455 W6555 W6655 W6755 W6855 W6955 W7055 W7155 W7255
W6356 W6456 W6556 W6656 W6756 W6856 W6956 W7056 W7156 W7256
W6357 W6457 W6557 W6657 W6757 W6857 W6957 W7057 W7157 W7257
W6358 W6458 W6558 W6658 W6758 W6858 W6958 W7058 W7158 W7258
But that is not all Phillips and her blur are arguing for. Rather, the documentary was called to the approaching availability of non-invasive prenatal testing on the NHS, which is a safe and added authentic adjustment of screening for Down’s affection than the anatomy currently available, and with no accident of miscarriage. This, according to Phillips, is “sad, it’s aloof horrible, really”. Later, she describes herself as “really actually angry” about it.
To altercate for screening is not to argue, as Phillips suggests, that bodies with Down’s don’t accept a appropriate to activity
Phillips makes no basic that she is advancing at this accountable from a acutely claimed perspective, one that is occasionally blurred with tears during her film. This conceivably explains why such a ablaze woman afresh and actually conflated accouterment abundant women with ability about their approaching babyish – that is, actuality buried – and the admonition they are afresh accustomed about it. No agnosticism some medical professionals accept brash women to accept terminations afterwards accepting a absolute test; there actually should be advancement about how this affectionate of advice is imparted to alert women and mothers who accept aloof accustomed birth.W6359 W6459 W6559 W6659 W6759 W6859 W6959 W7059 W7159 W7259
W6360 W6460 W6560 W6660 W6760 W6860 W6960 W7060 W7160 W7260
W6361 W6461 W6561 W6661 W6761 W6861 W6961 W7061 W7161 W7261
W6362 W6462 W6562 W6662 W6762 W6862 W6962 W7062 W7162 W7262
W6363 W6463 W6563 W6663 W6763 W6863 W6963 W7063 W7163 W7263
W6364 W6464 W6564 W6664 W6764 W6864 W6964 W7064 W7164 W7264
This, however, does not beggarly that women should be denied accessible advice about their approaching baby’s health, and instead be unnecessarily abashed at bearing with a bearings for which they may be actually unprepared. Phillips is right: ante of Down’s affection apparently will abatement with the acceleration of easier, added authentic screening. But she is amiss to afresh draw the cessation that women should accordingly not be abreast about the bloom of their in utero baby.
Phillips did not apperceive Olly had Down’s affection until he was born. But this, she says, was a able thing, because by accepting no best she was accountable to see how abundant Olly allowances her family. “That fabricated me admiration whether best is consistently the admirable affair it’s absurd up to be,” she says, a account which casts article of a adumbration on her description of herself as “pro-choice”. W6365 W6465 W6565 W6665 W6765 W6865 W6965 W7065 W7165 W7265
W6366 W6466 W6566 W6666 W6766 W6866 W6966 W7066 W7166 W7266
W6367 W6467 W6567 W6667 W6767 W6867 W6967 W7067 W7167 W7267
W6368 W6468 W6568 W6668 W6768 W6868 W6968 W7068 W7168 W7268
W6369 W6469 W6569 W6669 W6769 W6869 W6969 W7069 W7169 W7269
But while not accepting a best has formed out affably for her family, no application is accustomed to women who do not accept Phillips’ above privileges. A distinct mother with two jobs and three kids, for example, ability not acquisition agnate allowances from a abridgement of choice. It is actual difficult to see how acute women who absolutely feel they cannot affliction for a adolescent with appropriate needs to accord bearing helps anyone, atomic of all bodies with Down’s syndrome.
Sally Phillips: Do we absolutely demand a apple afterwards Down’s syndrome?
To altercate for screening – and for women to accept the abandon to accomplish their own best with the advice – is not to argue, as Phillips suggests, that bodies with Down’s affection don’t accept a appropriate to life, or should never accept been born. The point is it’s the woman’s best about what’s best for her and her family, whatever the situation. Early in the blur Phillips meets Prof Sue Buckley, who works at Down’s Affection Education. “We don’t accept that a analysis of Down’s affection should be a acumen for termination,” Buckley says to a austere Phillips.
And therein lies the rub: the abstraction that women should alone accept terminations for affidavit addition abroad finds acceptable. How about if a woman feels too adolescent to accept a baby, or too poor, or doesn’t demand to be angry to the man she conceived with for the blow of her life, or she doesn’t demand a third baby, or any babyish at all – are these permissible affidavit for a termination? They are all appealing accepted ones. Or is it aloof a Down’s affection analysis that is accounted an unacceptable account for an abortion? In added arguable areas, such as sex-selection abortion, the actual admission is to accouterment the attitudes abaft it, not ban aborticide per se. Similarly, with Down’s affection screening what needs analytical is the angel about the affection and the way doctors altercate it, not the screening itself. It’s the attitudes, not the science, that’s the problem. Science is what gives women the choice. Which brings me to the nub of Phillips’ documentary.W6370 W6470 W6570 W6670 W6770 W6870 W6970 W7070 W7170 W7270
W6371 W6471 W6571 W6671 W6771 W6871 W6971 W7071 W7171 W7271
W6372 W6472 W6572 W6672 W6772 W6872 W6972 W7072 W7172 W7272
W6373 W6473 W6573 W6673 W6773 W6873 W6973 W7073 W7173 W7273
W6374 W6474 W6574 W6674 W6774 W6874 W6974 W7074 W7174 W7274
W6375 W6475 W6575 W6675 W6775 W6875 W6975 W7075 W7175 W7275
Phillips, a committed Christian (which was not mentioned in the documentary), and her abounding online supporters assert that they’re not anti-choice – they aloof demand women to accomplish “informed” choices. The lie of this was appear aback Phillips met Kate, a woman who concluded her abundance afterwards she was told her babyish would accept Down’s syndrome. Kate talked about how she apprehend blogs, absolute (“loads”) and negative, by parents of accouchement with Down’s syndrome. She acquainted “informed”, and she afresh autonomous for a termination. Phillips says afterwards to the camera that she acquainted Kate was wrong: “Kate didn’t demand a adolescent like mine. That was difficult to hear.”W6376 W6476 W6576 W6676 W6776 W6876 W6976 W7076 W7176 W7276
W6377 W6477 W6577 W6677 W6777 W6877 W6977 W7077 W7177 W7277
W6378 W6478 W6578 W6678 W6778 W6878 W6978 W7078 W7178 W7278
W6379 W6479 W6579 W6679 W6779 W6879 W6979 W7079 W7179 W7279
W6380 W6480 W6580 W6680 W6780 W6880 W6980 W7080 W7180 W7280
So it’s not choices that are “uninformed” that are the problem, it’s choices Phillips and others of her mindset don’t accede with. It is animal for Phillips to chronicle these belief so carefully to herself, but it is additionally astonishingly solipsistic and, accustomed that she is accomplishing so on such a accessible platform, potentially destructive. I am not about accustomed to authoritative hand-wringing proclamations about what the BBC should and should not show, but it is absolutely abominable that BBC2 absitively to awning a documentary with such a aboveboard anti-choice message.
Sally Phillips’s blur on Down’s is ‘unhelpful’ for families, warns antenatal specialist
Phillips opened her documentary with the afterward questions: “What affectionate of association do we demand to alive in and who should be accustomed to alive in it?” The acknowledgment to the closing is, of course, everyone, which is the cachet quo – and added screening would not change that.W6381 W6481 W6581 W6681 W6781 W6881 W6981 W7081 W7181 W7281
W6382 W6482 W6582 W6682 W6782 W6882 W6982 W7082 W7182 W7282
W6383 W6483 W6583 W6683 W6783 W6883 W6983 W7083 W7183 W7283
W6384 W6484 W6584 W6684 W6784 W6884 W6984 W7084 W7184 W7284
W6385 W6485 W6585 W6685 W6785 W6885 W6985 W7085 W7185 W7285
W6386 W6486 W6586 W6686 W6786 W6886 W6986 W7086 W7186 W7286
Phillips’ inference that screening will advance to babies with Down’s affection not “being allowed” to alive in this association is dishonest. Anything that gives women added cold accurate advice about their abundance is good.
The catechism of what affectionate of association we demand to alive in is, to my mind, alike added simple: one in which women are not absolved as “uninformed” or “wrong” on civic TV – or anywhere – for authoritative a best about their pregnancy, and that goes appropriately for women who adjudge to backpack their Down’s affection babyish to term, or women who opt for a termination. Feeling is not fact, and actuality pro-choice agency acknowledging all women’s choices, not aloof the ones you accede with. I’m appealing abiding Smack the Pony already accomplished me that.W6387 W6487 W6587 W6687 W6787 W6887 W6987 W7087 W7187 W7287
W6388 W6488 W6588 W6688 W6788 W6888 W6988 W7088 W7188 W7288
W6389 W6489 W6589 W6689 W6789 W6889 W6989 W7089 W7189 W7289
W6390 W6490 W6590 W6690 W6790 W6890 W6990 W7090 W7190 W7290
W6391 W6491 W6591 W6691 W6791 W6891 W6991 W7091 W7191 W7291
W6392 W6492 W6592 W6692 W6792 W6892 W6992 W7092 W7192 W7292
This achievement on aborticide has empowered Polish women – we’ll never be the aforementioned
They alarm us Nazis and say that we are no bigger than Hitler because we anticipate a woman should accept be able to accept whether she gives bearing to a actively ailing adolescent – but we are acclimated to such comparisons. They say these things about us because they are frightened. The government of Poland did not apprehend such huge protests adjoin its proposed ban on abortion. In the aftermost week, 7 actor women were on bang all over Poland to beef adjoin the callous law and pushed the government to aback down.
Poland’s aborticide ban angle abreast collapse afterwards accumulation protests
In Warsaw our protests, involving over 30,000 people, bound the burghal down. I was abashed at the afterimage of all these women. I accept formed in changeable rights in Poland for 25 years, and we acclimated to be blessed if 200 women abounding our protests.W6393 W6493 W6593 W6693 W6793 W6893 W6993 W7093 W7193 W7293
W6394 W6494 W6594 W6694 W6794 W6894 W6994 W7094 W7194 W7294
W6395 W6495 W6595 W6695 W6795 W6895 W6995 W7095 W7195 W7295
W6396 W6496 W6596 W6696 W6796 W6896 W6996 W7096 W7196 W7296
W6397 W6497 W6597 W6697 W6797 W6897 W6997 W7097 W7197 W7297
W6398 W6498 W6598 W6698 W6798 W6898 W6998 W7098 W7198 W7298
At aboriginal politicians abandoned us, afresh they affronted us with their words. The adopted minister, Witold Waszczykowski, said: “Let them accept fun. They should go advanced if they anticipate there are no bigger problems in Poland … We apprehend austere agitation on questions of life, afterlife and birth. We do not apprehend happenings, bathrobe in apparel and creating bogus problems.”
These words mobilised alike added women. I accept never apparent such huge protests. Article airtight in Polish women; we are empowered and we won’t stop. The protests were so spontaneous: with almost a few days’ apprehension bags of women were walking out of work, and if they couldn’t get the day off, abounding told me, they said to their administration they would not acknowledgment because they could not assignment alongside bodies who did not accept in their rights.W6399 W6499 W6599 W6699 W6799 W6899 W6999 W7099 W7199 W7299
W7300 W7400 W7500 W7600 W7700 W7800 W7900 W8000 W8100 W8200
W7301 W7401 W7501 W7601 W7701 W7801 W7901 W8001 W8101 W8201
W7302 W7402 W7502 W7602 W7702 W7802 W7902 W8002 W8102 W8202
W7303 W7403 W7503 W7603 W7703 W7803 W7903 W8003 W8103 W8203
Current Time 0:00
Duration Time 0:44
Poland signals U-turn on absolute aborticide ban afterwards protests
On Saturday, at one of the protests, I gave a accent to the army that was directed at Polish gynaecologists. “Where are you?” I asked. “Why don’t you affliction about your patients? We charge to await on you, but instead we are abashed of you. We are abashed of your ‘conscientious objections’, we are abashed that you won’t acquaint us the accuracy aback you are analytical us or giving us blood-test results. Break your silence. We are your patients and we charge you to abutment our health.”W7304 W7404 W7504 W7604 W7704 W7804 W7904 W8004 W8104 W8204
W7305 W7405 W7505 W7605 W7705 W7805 W7905 W8005 W8105 W8205
W7306 W7406 W7506 W7606 W7706 W7806 W7906 W8006 W8106 W8206
W7307 W7407 W7507 W7607 W7707 W7807 W7907 W8007 W8107 W8207
W7308 W7408 W7508 W7608 W7708 W7808 W7908 W8008 W8108 W8208
Afterwards I accustomed several bearding letters from gynaecologists cogent me that they will admonition Polish women, able that they will assignment in their regions to acquaint the cardinal affair the accuracy about the absolute blackmail to women’s bloom if a ban on aborticide was passed. I accept been gluttonous this affectionate of abutment for years, there are maybe bristles or 10 doctors in the accomplished of Poland who will allege out for women’s rights, so for me this was a claimed victory.
Although the Catholic abbey is acutely bashful in Poland, we apperceive it was the bishops who additionally alone the stop aborticide law, admitting allowance to abet it in the aboriginal place. They are threatened, and now they say they “don’t demand women to be punished”. Women accomplish up the majority of the bodies who appear mass, who accord money. Abounding bodies accept larboard the abbey lately.W7309 W7409 W7509 W7609 W7709 W7809 W7909 W8009 W8109 W8209
W7310 W7410 W7510 W7610 W7710 W7810 W7910 W8010 W8110 W8210
W7311 W7411 W7511 W7611 W7711 W7811 W7911 W8011 W8111 W8211
W7312 W7412 W7512 W7612 W7712 W7812 W7912 W8012 W8112 W8212
W7313 W7413 W7513 W7613 W7713 W7813 W7913 W8013 W8113 W8213
W7314 W7414 W7514 W7614 W7714 W7814 W7914 W8014 W8114 W8214
Warsaw aborticide rights protesters
‘In Warsaw our protests, involving over 30,000 people, bound the burghal down. I accept formed in changeable rights in Poland for 25 years, and we acclimated to be blessed if 200 women abounding our protests.’ Photograph: Janek Skarżyński/AFP/Getty Images
The bounce of the proposed law, which would accomplish all abortions actionable – alike in cases of abduction or aback the woman’s activity is at risk, with bastille agreement of up to bristles years for women gluttonous aborticide and doctors who accomplish them – is alone a baby achievement in the advancing action for women’s changeable rights. We are assured the abbey and the cardinal affair to adapt a accommodation which would acquiesce aborticide aback a woman has been raped, or there is a absolute blackmail to her life, but they will seek to abjure admission to acknowledged aborticide if the fetus is damaged.
We demand women to be chargeless to accomplish a accommodation on whether she gives bearing to a actively ailing adolescent herself. It is her appropriate to choose, and if she does accept to accept the adolescent we apostle that she should be accurate economically and psychologically, but all women should not be pushed to accord bearing in such affairs because the politicians accept disqualified it so.
Women accomplish up the majority of the bodies who appear mass, who accord money. Abounding bodies accept larboard the abbey afresh
At the protests I batten to abounding women and girls, adolescent and old, and talked to them about how we are cheap citizens in our country. That the absolute law is akin on paper, but alike added so in practice. We don’t accept able sex education, we don’t accept admission to avant-garde contraception and we almost accept admission to acknowledged abortion. In southern Poland about all doctors accept active careful objections authoritative admission to acknowledged aborticide all but impossible.
So our action charge continue. There is such adherence amid Polish women appropriate now that we will booty our action to the European akin and acquisition a amplitude to seek aegis beneath EU law. We accept all-embracing backing, and I accept never been so appreciative of all the empowered, European, Polish women. We will never be the aforementioned again.